For my first Panthers post I am going to review the list of possible unrestricted free agents and see who the Panthers should try to sign. The Panthers have almost $26 million committed to 22 players (thanks to Irish Blue’s salary cap website and player salary spreadsheet). This includes salaries of some players who played in the minors last year and will probably play in Rochester or the ECHL this year. Taking these players out we have approximately $21,000,000 in 13 players. These players are listed below:
Forwards: Jokinen, Gratton, Peltonen, Olesz, Booth, Campbell, Larman and Stewart
Defencemen: Van Ryn, Salei, Bouwmeester, Mezei, Murphy
The team’s restricted free agents that I think they should keep and what I think they will be paid are as follows:
Allen ($1.75 million), Globke (600,000), Horton ($1.5 million), Jacina ($500,000), Kolnik ($1.2 million), Kreps ($650,000), Sprukts ($600,000), Weiss ($1.5 million), Welch ($750,000). I basically took last year’s salary and added small raises. I did not include Auld or Anderson (the goalies) or Montador or Semenov. I think the Panthers can go in a different direction from Alex Auld. I would not be opposed to Craig Anderson being brought back as a backup if the Panthers can get a #1 goalie who can play 60 or 65 games. I also did not include Montador or Semenov since the Panthers already have 7 defencemen under contract and I think if they are going to add anyone to this group it should be someone who can play in the top 4.
The Panthers have the following unrestricted free agents: Stumpel, Gelinas, Belfour, Vallin and Pelletier. I think the Panthers should re-sign Stumpel to a one year deal for $2 million. This is a small raise from what he made the last two seasons.
This leaves 23 players under contract for just over $32 million. I am assuming the Panthers are going to spend between $42 and 45 million which is lower than the current $47 million cap and will not come close to the expected $50-52 million salary cap. I will break down who is available and how much they should spend at each position:
Goalies:
Available free agents: Ed Belfour, Alex Auld, Craig Anderson, Jean-Sebastian Giguere (Ana), Dominik Hasek (Det), Jussi Markkanen (Edm), Mathieu Garon (LA), David Aebischer (Mtl), Kevin Weekes (NYR), Robert Esche (Phi), Curtis Joseph (Phx)
The Panthers could re-sign the Belfour/Auld combo for around $3 million but I don’t think this arrangement works. Belfour needs to be the #1 goalie to be effective and the Panthers do not have the margin of error to rely on Eddie for a full season. If I was Jacques Martin I would try to package the #10 pick in the first round of this year’s draft for either Vesa Toskala from San Jose or Ilya Bryzgalov from Anaheim. Both goalies can be #1’s in the league and have affordable contracts. Then the Panthers can re-sign Craig Anderson as the backup.
If this doesn’t work then I think then two of the Aebischer/Garon/Auld/Weekes group should be signed for around $3 million. A pair from this group could keep the team in games and the skaters should be better than last year.
I do not think Giguere is the answer for $7 million a year. I don’t think $3 or $4 extra million could make up for any additional production that Giguere could provide over the above options. Assuming the Panthers sign two goalies for a combined $3 million the Panthers would have $7 to $10 million to spend of forwards and defencemen.
Skaters:
The Panthers depth chart looks as follows with the players above:
Peltonen-Jokinen-Horton
Booth-Weiss-Olesz
Stewart-Stumpel-Kolnik
Sprukts-Gratton-Campbell
Extras: Larman, Globke, Jacina, Kreps
Salei-Bouwmeester
Van Ryn-Allen
Welch-Murphy
Extra: Mezei (Mezei can not be counted on as a regular. He is hurt too often).
The forwards do not have enough front line talent. They need two top 6 forwards and maybe a top 4 defenceman.
Available forwards that the Panthers should be interested in: Teemu Selanne (Ana), Daniel Briere (Buf), Chris Drury (Buf), Eric Lindros (Dal), Robert Lang (Det), Todd White (Min), Paul Kariya (Nsh), Scott Gomez (NJ), Jason Blake (NYI), Viktor Kozlov (NYI), Brendan Shanahan (NYR), Mike Comrie (Ott), Bill Guerin (SJ)
Of this group I don’t know if any of these guys are the answer. They can’t afford to give Briere or Drury $6 or $7 million a season. I think of this group they can go after Robert Lang. I’m thinking he will need around $3 million to sign. Todd White would be a cheaper option but I’m not sure you can be a playoff team with him in the top 6. I don’t see the older guys on the list like Shanahan, Kariya or Guerin coming to Florida because they will want to go to teams they think they are Cup contenders. I think the Panthers sign Lang for a deal around $3 million. Peltonen would have to be the 6th forward in this situation. This leaves $4 to $7 million to spend on a top 4 defenceman.
Available defencemen: Teppo Numminen (Buf), Brad Stuart (Cgy), Darryl Sydor (Dal), Mathieu Schneider (Det), Aaron Miller (LA), Sheldon Souray (Mtl), Kimmo Timonen (Nsh), Brian Rafalski (NJ), Tom Preissing (Ott), Craig Rivet (SJ)
I think the Panthers should go hard after Kimmo Timonen. A top 4 D of Timonen, Bouwmeester, Salei and Van Ryn would be just as good as everyone else in the league and a Murphy/Allen 5-6 pair would be very good. Otherwise the Panthers should try to get one more physical D like Miller or Rivet so Allen can be the #5 D where he can excel. Timonen would cost probably over $5 million which would take the rest of the cap room. Miller or Rivet would probably be $2.5 to 3 million.
After the above signings the Panthers would be in better shape than last year. It will not be a lock that the team will be in the playoffs but this is a team that is building to win in two or three years when Weiss, Horton and Bouwmeester hit their primes. Goaltending will probably be the difference in whether the Panthers can make the playoffs or not. If the Panthers can get a Bryzgalov or a Toskala I think the team will make the playoffs, otherwise the youngsters will have to make another step forward to carry the team.
Thanks for reading.